Dagata s notes to his readers at the beginning of his first two anthologies were marked by an adamant, prescriptive tone, but in the lifespan of a fact he takes the gloves off and becomes. John d agata on broadways the lifespan of a fact author john d agata discusses his book being transformed into a broadway play. As some might remember, there was a bit of an uproar this past winter over a thin, somewhat funnylooking book called the lifespan of a fact by john dagata and jim fingal. The lifespan of a fact is a book cowritten by john dagata and jim fingal and published by w. Lets talk about that special literary form that we shall call the preacher story. Jul, 2017 this, the new book the lifespan of a fact makes clear, can be an epic trial. If a mirror were a sufficient means of handling human experience, he writes. The lifespan of a fact, by john dagata and jim fingal a correspondence between a writer and a factchecker becomes an exploration of the use of facts and fiction as the writer tries. In 2012, awardwinning essayist john dagata and fact checker jim fingal released their attimes heated discussion in the book, the lifespan of a fact. Feb 26, 2012 the essayist john dagata wrestles with a fact checker over questions of truth, beauty and accuracy. Essays, about a mountain, and the lifespan of a fact, as well as the editor of the 3volume series a new history of the essay, which includes the anthologies the next american essay, the making of the american essay, and the lost origins of the essay. In 2003, an essay by john dagata was rejected by the magazine that commissioned it due to factual inaccuracies.
In 2018, the lifespan of a fact was made into a broadway, oneact play starring daniel radcliffe, cherry jones, and bobby cannavale. The lifespan of a fact, by john dagata and jim fingal. This process forms the core of the lifespan of a fact, a 123page annotated essay cowritten by john dagata, author, and jim fingal, fact checker. The essayist john d agata makes an obrienesque claim about the difference between storytruth and happeningtruth in his new book the lifespan of a fact norton. The four stars are because there is a lot here for a reader consider. Pdf download the lifespan of a fact free unquote books. Sep 07, 2012 as some might remember, there was a bit of an uproar this past winter over a thin, somewhat funnylooking book called the lifespan of a fact by john dagata and jim fingal. The first question one encounters in this book is simply, how best to read it. This, i think, is clearly a case of a book preaching to its choir. Written by jeremy kareken and david murrell and produced by the team behind glengarry glen ross and spring awakening, the lifespan of a fact will run for sixteen weeks at the famous studio 54. Buy the lifespan of a fact book online at low prices in.
In 2003, after publishing his book of experimental essays, halls of fame, john dagata was approached by harpers magazine to write. Click download or read online button to get the lifespan of a fact book now. Dagata then resold the essay to the believer, where he met fingal, who would. The lifespan of a fact is two things in one both an essay about the suicide of a young man who leaped from a las vegas hotel, and the notes of a factchecker trying to verify the information in the essay. In 2003, john dagata wrote an essay that was rejected by the magazine that commissioned it because it contained factual inaccuracies. By the end of the book, he has uncovered so many inaccuracies in the various coroners reports and news stories about the event that its hard to say if dagatas essay is really so inaccurate after all. Called by npr the most improbably entertaining book ever written, the lifespan of a fact is a retrospectively reconstructed and embellished exchange between dagata and. Those who choose to read a windy transcript of a dispute between an essayist john dagata and a factchecker jim fingal on the struggle between fact and truth are perhaps predisposed to enjoy it.
The literary essay takes the stage as john cannavale and jim radcliffe debate the difference between art and facts as their editor jones referees. Daniel radcliffe, cherry jones and bobby cannavale star in the worldpremiere adaptation of john d agata and jim fingals book the lifespan of a fact, about journalistic integrity and poetic. John dagata is the author of halls of fame, about a mountain, and the lifespan of a fact, as well as the editor of the 3volume series a new history of the essay. Feb 07, 2012 thus begins the alternately absorbing and infuriating exercise that is the lifespan of a fact, a talmudically arranged account of the conflict between jim fingal, zealous checker, and john dagata, nonfiction fabulist. The lifespan of a fact doesnt really even look like a book. Mar 08, 2012 the lifespan of a fact also contains the correspondence that passed between d agata and fingal during the fact checking process. In 2003, after publishing his book of experimental essays, halls of fame, john dagata was approached by. Thus begins the alternately absorbing and infuriating exercise that is the book the lifespan of a fact, a talmudically arranged account of the conflict between jim fingal, zealous checker, and john d agata, nonfiction fabulist, which began in 2005 and resulted in this collaboration. In 2003, dagata penned a piece for the believer about a young man.
The lifespan of a fact, book and play, are based on a real life story. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. An innovative essayist and his fact checker do battle about the use of truth and the definition of nonfiction. Mar 07, 2012 coauthored by lyric essayist and university of iowa professor john d agata and his former fact checker jim fingal, the lifespan of a fact is the record of their combative correspondence. Feb 07, 2011 john d agata is the author of halls of fame, about a mountain, and the lifespan of a fact, as well as the editor of the 3volume series a new history of the essay, which includes the anthologies the next american essay, the making of the american essay, and the lost origins of the essay.
Jeremy kareken, david murrell, and gordon farrells the lifespan of a fact wrestles with that question in the latest asolo rep production. Now, their debate over truth versus accuracy is on stage, both on broadway starring daniel radcliffe, and in salt lake city. The lifespan of a fact might be the most improbably entertaining book ever published. The paperback of the the lifespan of a fact by john dagata, jim fingal. The book is written in a nontraditional format consisting of dagata s 2003 essay what happens there in black text centered on each page with fingals black and red comments and occasional correspondence with.
I am very frustrated with john dagata and jim fingals the lifespan of a fact. John dagata redefines the essay electric literature. The lifespan of a fact, by john d agata and jim fingal. Thus begins the alternately absorbing and infuriating exercise that is the book the lifespan of a fact, a talmudically arranged account of the conflict between jim fingal, zealous checker, and john dagata, nonfiction fabulist, which began in 2005 and resulted in this collaboration. There are words that may keep this from being read by many people and the suicide of a teen age is not likely to be a topic for family night reading. Lifespan of a fact john d agata and jim fingal will read from their new book, the lifespan of a fact, which focuses on the question of how. His newest anthology, the making of the american essay, the third in a series, has sparked even more debate over the very definition of. Alas, i am neither pretentious enough nor overeducated enough to appreciate the dickwadery presented in this book. From the lifespan of a fact, by writer john dagata and jim fingal, published in february 2012 by w. The book is written in a nontraditional format consisting of dagata s 2003 essay what happens there in black text centered on each page with fingals black and red comments and occasional correspondence with dagata making up two columns that surround and. Mikes been meaning to get to some of dagata s work for years now, despite having some mixed feelings about his relationship to the truth and truthiness as explicated in the book the lifespan of a fact, which traced the backandforth between dagata and a factchecker at the believer who found a number of factual errors in his.
Feb 15, 2012 the essayist john dagata makes an obrienesque claim about the difference between storytruth and happeningtruth in his new book the lifespan of a fact norton. In 2003, after publishing his book of experimental essays, halls of fame, john dagata was approached by harpers magazine to write an essay for them, one that was eventually rejected due to disagreements related to its fact checking. Halls of fame graywolf press, 2001 about a mountain w. Buy the lifespan of a fact book online at best prices in india on.
It is not apropos to the moment and does not serve d agata. Maggie nelson thus begins the alternately absorbing and infuriating exercise that is the lifespan of a fact, a talmudically arranged account of the conflict between jim fingal, zealous checker, and john d agata, nonfiction fabulist. It was not accepted, but another periodical, the believer assigned a factchecker, jim fingal, to examine the piece. The lifespan of a fact by john dagata and jim fingal. The play is based on a book of the same title, written by the real life john dagata and jim fingal, documenting the lengthy edit process dagata s 2003 essay, what happens there. John dagata couldnt help but chuckle the first time he heard that the lifespan of a fact, a book he coauthored in 2012, could be a play. John dagata is the author of halls of fame, about a mountain, and the lifespan of a fact, as well as the editor of the 3volume series a new history of the essay, which includes the anthologies the next american essay, the making of the american essay, and the lost origins of the essay. On 2003 harpers magazine approached author john dagata halls of fame to write a lengthy piece motivated by the suicide of a teenager levi presley by jumping in las vegas. The book consists of the increasingly heated exchange between dagata and his factchecker, jim fingal, as he tries. John dagata author of the lifespan of a fact 2012 at.
What we have in the lifespan of a fact is that essay with constant responses by the factchecker, jim fingal. The lifespan of a fact by john d agata, 9780393340730, download free ebooks, download free pdf epub ebook. John dagata s lyric essays and his defense of the essay as art form have been at the center of an ongoing discussion on the roles of fact and truth in the literary arts. The essayist john dagata wrestles with a fact checker over questions of truth, beauty and accuracy. Jul 14, 2016 john dagata s lyric essays and his defense of the essay as art form have been at the center of an ongoing discussion on the roles of fact and truth in the literary arts.
It is not apropos to the moment and does not serve dagata. The lifespan of a fact by john dagata, 9780393340730, download free ebooks, download free pdf epub ebook. In real life, fingal refuses to say dagata won the argument completely. The lifespan of a fact, a book by john dagata, a writer, and jim fingal, a former intern and factchecker at the believer, purports to explore this question by documenting fingals. The central question of the book is whether writing that is billed as nonfiction, such as an essay, has a moral obligation to be as factual accurate as possible. The lifespan of a fact by john dagata and jim fingal 2012 128 pages nonfiction okay preachers, i am talking to you now. The lifespan of a fact is a brilliant and eyeopening meditation on the relationship between truth and accuracy, and a penetrating conversation about whether it is appropriate for a writer to substitute one for the other. Norton such was the case with john dagata and jim fingal. In 2010, john dagatas book about a mountain was released, billed as the story of plans to locate a nuclear waste storage facility near las. The lifespan of a fact john dagata jim fingal download. Apr 17, 2012 while john d agata is a passionate advocate and practitioner of the essay, he is also polite, wellspoken, and reasoned in his defense of manipulating facts and eschewing the label of nonfiction. The story centered on the death of a teenaged boy and explored issues around the high suicide rate in las vegas. It is a highlevel discussion of a very particular type of writing, the essay.
John dagata the lifespan of a fact is now a major broadway play. Now a broadway play starring daniel radcliffe provocative, maddening and compulsively readable maggie nelson in 2003, american essayist john dagata wrote a piece for harpers about las vegass alarmingly high suicide rate, after a sixteenyearold boy had thrown himself from the. The lifespan of a fact download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. In 2003, an essay by john d agata was rejected by the magazine that commissioned it due to factual inaccuracies.
John dagata english college of liberal arts and sciences. Jim fingal, an intern at the believ er magazine, was tasked to fact check a john dagata piece. Dagata and fingal contribute to the discussion with the format of their book. John d agata says no, but in my opinion that depends on the context. His newest anthology, the making of the american essay, the third in a series. The preacher story generally has two characteristics. The essayist john dagata makes an obrienesque claim about the difference between storytruth and happeningtruth in his new book the lifespan of a fact norton. When fingal got in touch with d agata to ask some followup. Harpers magazine had commissioned the piece, but ultimately refused to publish it. The lifespan of a fact 2012 read online free book by john d. John dagata is the author of halls of fame, about a mountain, and the lifespan of a fact, as well as the editor of the 3volume series a new history of the essay, which includes the anthologies the next american essay, the making of the american essay. Books john dagata the lifespan of a fact is now a major. The lifespan of a fact is a quick read, but it left me wanting more in a certain way.
The lifespan of a fact by john dagata and jim fingal mosaic. His most recent book, the lifespan of a fact, presents d agata s arguments by way of example. The lifespan of a fact by john dagata and jim fingal the. Sep 19, 2018 john dagata couldnt help but chuckle the first time he heard that the lifespan of a fact, a book he coauthored in 2012, could be a play. In 2005, as an intern at the believer, fingal began factchecking dagata s article on the 2002 suicide of las vegas teenager levi presley. It is a good book, but a prospective reader needs to know that this is not about journalism. In the book, d agata and fingal discuss whether it is appropriate to change facts in writing that is both nonfiction and art. Essays, about a mountain, and the lifespan of a fact, as well as the editor of the 3volume series a new history of the essay. Daniel radcliffe stars in broadway play based on iowans story. Ui nonfiction directors book spins into broadway play the. Author dagata makes the argument that an essay should not be held to journalistic standards, and that the. An innovative essayist and his factchecker do battle about the use of truth and the definition of nonfiction. The lifespan of a fact 2012 read online free book by.
The lifespan of a fact by john dagata, jim fingal, paperback. Geniusin the lifespan of a fact, dagata and fingal turn everything around on us until even our most basic assumptions are left uncleara vivid and reflective meditation on the nature of nonfiction as literary art. Under consideration in this essay is the lifespan of a fact, which is less a book than a knockdown, dragout fight between two tenacious combatants, over questions of truth, belief, history, myth, memory and forgetting. Fingals talmudic factchecking commentary reflected in the books. Hell attend several more performances as the play moves to its official. In 2003, after publishing his book of experimental essays, halls of fame, john d agata was approached by harpers magazine to write an essay for them, one that was eventually rejected due to disagreements related to its fact checking. If you listen to preaching, youre welcome to listen in. Coauthored by lyric essayist and university of iowa professor john dagata and his former factchecker jim fingal, the lifespan of a fact is the record of their combative correspondence. Under consideration in this essay is the lifespan of a fact, which is less a book. John maintains that he is an essayist, not a writer of nonfiction, a. Pdf the lifespan of a fact download full pdf book download. Gideon lewiskraus, new york times magazine geniusin the lifespan of a fact. In 2005, as an intern at the believer, fingal began factchecking dagatas article on the 2002 suicide of las vegas teenager levi presley.
The book was a serious experiment in postmodern playfulness, a socratic dialogue irl there really was, it seems, a levi presley, who killed himself by suicide and last year it became a broadway play, starring daniel radcliffe, who interned at the new yorker in order to get a feel for the whole factchecking thing. Nov 16, 2017 in the book the lifespan of a fact, john dagata and jim fingal engage in a debate about truth and what the writers role and responsibility is in presenting the truth in a work of literature. In 2010, john d agata s book about a mountain was released, billed as the story of plans to locate a nuclear waste. The lifespan of a fact, by john dagata and jim fingal the new. Harpers rejected the original essay, dagata s what happens there, due to factual discrepancies. From the very start, the reader realizes that dagata alters actuality or even fabricates occurrences in his essay about the suicide of a teenage. This book includes an early draft of dagatas essay, along with dagata and fingals extensive discussion around the text. There are two ways to react to the discomfort the lifespan of a fact provokes.
261 256 204 1031 573 246 234 379 1047 865 1075 677 193 1416 1198 1039 176 1433 101 890 1318 1078 567 716 805 264 177 1407 720 992 361 885 468 1357 1255 1427 607 566 1151 185 70 955 836